Today marks 49 years since 26-year-old Sister Roberta Elam was found on a hillside near the Sisters of St. Joseph motherhouse in Ohio County, West Virginia, a discovery that launched an investigation that remains active nearly five decades later.
Earlier that day, Sister Robin had been participating in a silent retreat on the property. When she was discovered in a nearby field, investigators found her belongings scattered across the area and an overturned bench on the hillside, clues that immediately raised questions about what had happened during her final hours. Witnesses were interviewed, tips were pursued, and authorities worked to identify anyone who may have crossed paths with her that afternoon.
Over the years, investigators examined numerous leads. A rusty gray or blue car reportedly seen in the area was investigated and ruled out. Composite sketches were created based on witness descriptions, but those efforts failed to identify a suspect. As the years passed, the case grew cold.
Then in 2002, preserved evidence gave investigators a new avenue to pursue. Authorities were able to recover a DNA profile believed to belong to the person responsible. Since then, that DNA has reportedly been compared to dozens of individuals, including local residents, persons of interest, and convicted offenders. Investigators have even used familial DNA testing to examine one frequently discussed lead, but no match was found.
Nearly five decades later, investigators say the DNA is there. What remains unknown is whose DNA it is. Sister Robin's case remains active, and authorities continue to hope modern forensic advances will finally provide the answer that has remained out of reach since 1977.
Full story 👇
… See MoreSee Less