More than forty years after her daughter vanished, Janice McKinney is still searching for answers about what happened to her daughter Cherrie. Recently, that search led somewhere unexpected, to her own mailbox.
After a member of the volunteer group that supports Janice reached out to an incarcerated man based on tips, he responded with a claim that immediately drew attention. He wrote that members of his own family were responsible for what happened to eight-year-old Cherrie Mahan. From there, he and Janice began exchanging letters. He maintains that he was not directly involved, only that he knows what his relatives were capable of, keeping himself close to the story while stopping short of placing himself inside it.
When that first letter arrived, Janice did what she has done for decades and followed the lead.
A visit was arranged, and she traveled to the prison prepared to sit across from him and ask the questions that have been waiting since 1985. When she arrived, he declined to meet with her. However with his release expected within the next few months, the possibility of a conversation remains on the table.
To understand why any of this matters, you have to go back to February 22, 1985. That afternoon in Winfield Township, Pennsylvania, Cherrie stepped off her school bus and began walking toward her home. It was a Friday afternoon in rural Butler County. The bus pulled away, and somewhere between that stop and her front door, Cherrie disappeared.
Before long, people started talking about a vehicle seen near the bus route. Witnesses described a bright blue 1976 Dodge van with a mountain scene and a skier painted along the side, and some accounts placed it following the bus that afternoon.
Search crews moved through the surrounding woods and fields while flyers carrying Cherrie’s photo spread far beyond western Pennsylvania, reaching communities that had never heard her name before that winter. Despite years of tips and periodic renewed searches, the bright blue Dodge van with the skier and mountain mural was never conclusively identified, and no confirmed trace of Cherrie has ever been found.
More than four decades later, the investigation remains open, and that painted van is still one of the clearest details anyone can point to. Janice continues to follow each new lead as it comes, hoping that one of them will finally explain what happened after the bus pulled away that afternoon in Butler County.
More info👇
… See MoreSee Less