Nearly 49 years ago this week, Cheryl Hughes left her Chillicothe, Ohio, home to pick up a pizza and never came back. What happened next turned into one of southern Ohio's most enduring unsolved mysteries. A few days later, Cheryl's body was discovered along a rural road near South Shore, Kentucky, about 60 miles from where she disappeared. Investigators spent years trying to piece together what happened, but the case has never been solved.
One person who refused to let Cheryl be forgotten was her best friend since childhood, Janet Donahue. The two worked together at the RCA plant in Circleville, and before Cheryl disappeared, Janet says Cheryl confided that she was having an affair with a city police officer. As the years passed and answers never came, Janet took an extraordinary step. She earned her private investigator's license, placed newspaper ads, and spent decades trying to uncover what happened to her friend.
The case only became more frustrating with time. According to a 2019 report, the original investigative file is gone, reportedly lost after water damage. Today, little remains beyond old newspaper articles, fading memories, and an 11-page Kentucky State Police summary that begins with a line many followers of the case have never forgotten: "To say the least, this is a very confusing case." Nearly five decades later, Cheryl Hughes' family and friends are still waiting for the answers that disappeared with her on that July night in 1977.
More info 👇
… See MoreSee Less