Joseph Chaffins was 26 years old when he disappeared from North Webster, Indiana, on October 26, 2022. He had reportedly been dropped off in the area of EMS W23 Lane and Backwater Road. What happened to him after that is still a mystery.
Joseph was originally from Kentucky and moved with his family to Kosciusko County when he was 18. According to his family, he loved to fish and spent a lot of time outdoors.
Interestingly enough, someone had taken a photo of Joseph just three days before he disappeared, later shared by WNDU. The photo shows him walking along the south side of Webster Lake, in the same general area where he would go missing only days later.
In the years since, investigators have followed some pretty serious leads. Cadaver dogs have been brought to six different locations in the search for Joseph, and police have received tips claiming that he had passed away and was buried on various properties. Some of those tips were taken seriously enough that investigators brought in excavation equipment from the county highway department and actually dug, with permission from the property owners. But they didn't find Joseph.
In January 2025, the Kosciusko County Sheriff's Office made another public push for information, saying the investigation remained active and they were continuing to follow up on any information that came in.
Then, in August 2025, Joseph's mother and siblings gathered near the Backwater Webster boat launch for a vigil. It had been nearly three years since Joseph disappeared from that same general area, and despite all the searches, tips and places investigators had dug, they were still without answers. This October marks four years since Joseph's disappearance, he would be 30 years old.
If you have any information regarding Joseph’s whereabouts investigators want to speak with you. They've asked anyone who may know something, no matter how small, to come forward.
More info👇
… See MoreSee Less